Pema Chödrön on Uncertainty: When Things Fall Apart

Pema Chödrön's most famous book is When Things Fall Apart — and the title alone is enough to explain why her work resonates with millions of people who would never describe themselves as Buddhist.

She became a nun after two divorces and the collapse of her own life. This is not incidental to her teaching: her authority comes from having lived the dissolution she writes about, not from having avoided it.

The Core Teaching: Groundlessness as Practice

Most spiritual and self-help frameworks promise some version of stability — get the right practice, the right insight, the right habits, and you will find ground. A place to stand.

Chödrön's teaching is the opposite: the ground is always falling away, and learning to be in free fall is the practice.

She uses the Tibetan concept of bardo — the in-between state, the liminal space between what was and what will be. Most of us spend enormous energy trying to get out of bardo, to reach the other side as quickly as possible. Her instruction is to learn to inhabit it.

This is not masochism. It is the recognition that the resistance to groundlessness — the panic, the grasping, the desperate attempts to fix what is unraveling — produces more suffering than the groundlessness itself.

Tonglen: Breathing in Suffering

The most distinctive practice Chödrön teaches is tonglen — which translates roughly as "giving and receiving." The instruction is counterintuitive:

Breathe in what is difficult, painful, unwanted. Breathe out relief, space, ease.

This is the inverse of most relaxation and visualization practices, which instruct you to breathe in light and breathe out darkness. Tonglen deliberately moves toward what is difficult.

The logic: what we resist persists. When we can breathe into our own pain — and extend that capacity to breathe into the pain of others — the resistance dissolves and, paradoxically, space opens.

This practice is particularly relevant for caregivers, healthcare workers, and anyone in sustained contact with suffering. Rather than protecting themselves from the suffering (which eventually leads to compassion fatigue), tonglen trains the capacity to be present with it without being overwhelmed.

The Three Kinds of Suffering

Chödrön identifies three forms of suffering:

Ordinary suffering — physical pain, emotional pain, the frustrations and disappointments of daily life.

Suffering of change — the impermanence of what we enjoy; the anxiety of knowing everything will eventually end.

Pervasive suffering — the underlying anxiety of existence itself; what Buddhism calls dukkha.

Her teaching: we can't eliminate any of these. What we can do is stop adding the layer of secondary suffering — the fighting against, the "this shouldn't be happening," the desperate attempts to maintain what cannot be maintained.

Practical Application: What This Looks Like in Daily Life

When life is falling apart: resist the impulse to immediately fix, solve, or reframe. Sit with the discomfort for three breaths before doing anything. Not as self-punishment — as recognition.

When you encounter someone suffering: rather than immediately offering solutions (a reflex that serves us more than them), practice receiving what they're experiencing. Let it land. This is tonglen in conversation.

When you feel groundless: instead of "when will this end?", try "what is actually here right now?" The shift from future-focused panic to present-moment inquiry is the heart of Chödrön's practical teaching.

FAQ

What is Pema Chödrön's most important book?

When Things Fall Apart is the most widely read. The Places That Scare You and Comfortable with Uncertainty are also foundational.

What is tonglen meditation?

Tonglen is a Tibetan meditation practice of breathing in suffering (your own and others') and breathing out relief. It is the inverse of most relaxation practices and works by training the capacity to be present with difficulty rather than avoiding it.

Is Pema Chödrön's teaching Buddhist?

Yes, it is rooted in Tibetan Buddhism (Shambhala tradition). But her practical teachings on uncertainty, impermanence, and self-compassion are widely applicable regardless of religious background.

Recommended Reading

📚 When Things Fall Apart — Pema Chödrön. Her most widely read work, written after her own period of dissolution.

📚 Radical Acceptance — Tara Brach. A complementary Western clinical framework for working with what is difficult.

Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.